SOAP vs. REST: Pragmatic case studies?
I'm not satisfied with the answers given by the SOAP vs REST questions notably here: Performance of SOAP vs. XML-RPC or REST
because it's just general philosophical answers and not pragmatic answers with some study cases.
Nobody can give precise cases of when soap would be more suitable than rest, especially as for performance point of view ?
Update:I think REST is winning the war.
WSO2 Identity Server : I am new to WSO2 Identity Server. Could somebody help to get list of REST call and soap call supported by WSO2 Identity Server
I was just curious , currently the address in my WSDL SOAP File is <wsdl:port name=MyPort binding=tns:MyBinding> <soap:address location=http://localhost:87/SomeMethod/> </wsdl:po
I've frequently used SOAP over HTTP for web services that so far worked great and with REST this is only choice we're left with. I would like to know If you've come across a use case/scenario in your
Technology: C#.NET, REST Full Webservices, ASMX WebServices. We are porting existing ASMX Webservices to REST Full services. This is done to cut off the overheads SOAP wrapping has been producing and
I've read a little about REST and SOAP technologies and I understand REST is simpler than SOAP, but what about working with REST in Oracle 11g? Oracle 11g uses his framework to handle the SOAP's compl
I'm principally interested in case studies on code metrics, relating code readability to defect reduction, that justify taking seriously cyclomatic complexity or some similar metric. Wikipedia has thi
I'm having a problem with an API that uses SOAP. My client is written in PHP and produces the following: <?xml version=1.0 encoding=UTF-8?> <SOAP-ENV:Envelope xmlns:SOAP-ENV=http://schem
I have been reading up on the differences between SOAP and REST. I am getting the impression that SOAP would be used for a service that would invoke behavior, provide a contract and address interopera
I have to create a media service to prepare services to our other applications. the question is that our API should be REST or SOAP? I read a lot of articles and materials that compare these two metho
I have part of my rails 2 webservice application which is used as SOAP service (historical reasons, rest of app is REST). Just two operations AddLead and ShowLead, with wsdl on /soap/wsdl. I want to t
I have that error : Operation 'GetFields' in contract 'IService' uses a MessageContract that has SOAP headers. SOAP headers are not supported by the None MessageVersion. The problem is that my opera
Generally, I used the Soap web service. Now I want to use rest web services. I tried but I am unable to understand it. Here I provided the soap web service for the login. How can I write it for Rest?
Besides readability is there any significant benifit to using a CASE WHEN statement vs ISNULL/NULLIF when guarding against a divide by 0 error in SQL? CASE WHEN (BeginningQuantity + BAdjustedQuantity)
I know there are a couple of post on StackOverflow about REST and Thrift for HBase, but I would like to focus a bit on the question of performance. I have been playing with the following libraries in
It appears the query string parameters you can pass to a rest method in WCF REST is case insesitive - actually this makes sense. What the best naming convention for parameters with 2 words, using an _
I need Clear case plug-in for VS 2008 on Win7 64 bit machine. Can anyone suggest a good option? - Ram
I am having problems whenever I am trying to run my client app using SOAP or REST. No matter what, I seem to get rejected on the localhost. I verified I have the correct ports for both services so tho
I'm just learning REST and trying to figure out how to apply it in practice. I have a sampling of data that I want to query, but I'm not sure how the URLs are meant to be formed, i.e. where I put the
Possible Duplicate: Java vs C#: Are there any studies that compare their execution speed? Which one would be faster? I imagine C# since it's basically targeted only towards Windows. Assuming either
I am attempting to create a new Case object using the REST API but need to find out how to format the JSON body to pass in nested SObjects. It's not apparent in the Docs, and I can't seem to find any
If I get it, Apache Sling acts a REST CRUD interface for a Jackrabbit JCR repository. As there already exists a RESTful protocol (CMIS in its AtomPub implementation) to work with JCR repositories, apa
We have an upcoming project to allow an old platform that's only extensible with C++ / VS 2003 to call a SOAP-based web service that uses WS-Security. My Google research indicates that gSOAP could be
I am new to WSO2 and don't know how to use the declaritive programming widgets to create the REST contract. My use case; I have a backend SOAP 1.2 Web Service that I want to wrap with a REST API in WS
I was wondering if it's possible to deploy/use a SOAPUI mock service as a war on Apache Tomcat, giving the fact that it uses the context script object in order to run a test case.
I need to give a demo on the working of Soap and Rest(practical example). Could anyone help please and suggest an example using .net frame work or any other suitable ways. Let me put it this way I w
I want to call a SOAP service using REST service. Can anybody please share some example programme or snippets where we can invoke a soap service using JAX-RS(Jersey) written REST service. I am using j
I'm not completely clear on one thing and am hoping some one here will probably answer this. I worked on an enterprise application where we had a Java app consuming services with a WSDL interface in b
I'm currently using twisted's perspective broker on python and I have considered in the past switching to something like RabbitMQ but I'm not sure it could just replace pb - I feel like I might be com
Is it possible to achieve all the functionality using REST API, which can be achieved using OTA. I do understand that there are examples given in both OTA and REST API Documentation, which is provided
I just got a doubt whether the XMLs we are using for our SOAP/REST-based web services are case-sensitive or or not? How does it work exactly? Tell me both for the default soap envelope as well as for
Problem Statement: We have built MVC 4 application using WCF Service library (not WCF Service Application with svc file). All of the MVC CRUD operations we are doing through WCF SOAP Service library.E
We've got REST and SOAP endpoints for our service so we use WebFaultException to pass friendly messages. This works great for the REST calls not so much for the SOAP calls. Below is the trace which cl
The Pragmatic Programmer is highly recommended by many people. I've just finished reading it, and I can see why people recommend it, although I would point out that Code Complete covers almost all of
Is it possible to intercept binding of XML/JSON data coming through SOAP or REST webservice, to modify/check some of the data ? let's say I have methods like this on my webservice: @WebMethod public
We are currently using Spring MVC to implement REST services. We need to expose a subset of these service implementations as SOAP. I looked into apache camel documentation to see if there is any such
I would like to know that web service clearly means the usage of WSDL file and SOAP protocol (mainly WSDL) or it may mean the REST API, too?
How do I simply understand wsdl's? Seems very complicated. How is it related to soap? Where does rest fit in all these? Please give examples.
I am reading the The Pragmatic programmer and doing the following exercise in .net world (Chapter 3 - Code Generators) The Exercise Write a code generator that takes the input in Listing 1, and gener
Is REST a better approach to doing Web Services or is SOAP? Or are they different tools for different problems? Or is it a nuanced issue - that is, is one slightly better in certain arenas than anothe
I am using Oracle service bus to handle REST based services. I need to handle REST to POST conversion in OSB. Bcse ma back-end is a SOAP system. This is a request generated from OSB <soapenv:Body x
I'm trying to use gSoap2.8 with VS2010 C++ project I declared a pre-build event wsdl2h.exe -o test.h test.wsdl then it says error C1083: Cannot open type library file:<path>\stlvector.h: Err
Is it possible (Java EE, JBoss 6) to cleverly annotate Java code to provide both RESTful and SOAP webservices without implementing two methods? I'm thinking about: @Local @Path(/service) @WebService
What is the use of target namespace and SOAP endpoint and where to get these in a SOAP request using savon gem? I'm using savon gem to send a soap request. From the documentation it says that: In case
I'm amazed that years over years IT pretend to simplify communication or software design and a few years later it declare it was over-engineered. EJB, SOAP, so looking at all the WCF stuffs do we as u
I am getting a SOAP response for a SOAP call perfectly using SOAP ui but when I call the same in php, I am not able to traverse to the desired element(CreditId in this case), which I want. The followi
How is the element in the Soap Envelope different from the HTTP headers? Why are REST responses considered human readable whereas SOAP are not? When using SOAP services in PHP with the SoapClient() cl
I've recently created a java project with the associated RallyRestToolkit jar files. The intent for my code is to create a new TestCaseResult to the specified Test Case. The code currently works in Ec
I'm currently building a Koa app with the Firebase Node library. Is there a speed difference between using that compared to REST?
When I read Pragmatic Bookshelf's books, it has the following format How can I do that with LaTeX? Line numbers at the left side, coloring source code, and grayed source name. What's the tools for s
I have VS 2013 and Specflow installed. It seems the comment selection(Ctrl+K, Ctrl+C) and uncomment selection (Ctrl+K, Ctrl+U) are disabled in case of .feature file. Doesn't matter whether it is enabl